Provenance manifest: Manchester City found guilty of financial fair play breaches
Output: video.mp4 in this folder (30 seconds), rendered from animation.html (web page: index.html; web version of this manifest: manifest.html). Storyline 1 of storylines-data/manchester-city.json.
Built by outputs/motion-kit/motion.py, which checks every quote and figure below against the fetched article text before the animation is written. The animation reads its words only from this list, so what is on screen is exactly what is listed here.
Entries are grouped by the beat of the video in which they appear, in order. Labels (dates, stage names) are marked as such. Narrated lines are listed under the beat in which they are spoken (sections marked "narration"), follow the same rules as on-screen text, and are also collected with their timings in narration.md.
Three things are generated from the Storylines data and not listed entry by entry: the Storyline title (used exactly as given), the end card crediting each article by headline and date, and the Read more list on the web page. The soundtrack is music and sound effects synthesised in code by outputs/motion-kit/audio.py (no samples, no licensed music, no speech), so it adds no words or facts. The end card closes with the line "Every fact on screen comes from these articles · theguardian.com". The date rail's stop labels are the dates of the beats listed below.
0:00 · Title
1Guardian reporting, 25–28 September 2026
- NoteSpan of publication dates of the Storyline’s key stories.
0:02 · How it got here
2How it got here
- NoteHeading for the background beat.
3A process a decade in the making
- SourceManchester City found guilty of breaking Premier League’s financial fair play rules (25 September 2026)
- Supports
The extent of the charge sheet reflected a process that had been a decade in the making.
42015
- SourceManchester City found guilty of breaking Premier League’s financial fair play rules (25 September 2026)
- Supports
hacked and made public in 2015
5Football Leaks: millions of private documents made public
- SourceManchester City found guilty of breaking Premier League’s financial fair play rules (25 September 2026)
- Supports
The Football Leaks affair, in which millions of private documents relating to football clubs and players were hacked and made public in 2015, led to reporting on City’s affairs
6Dec 2018
- SourceManchester City found guilty of breaking Premier League’s financial fair play rules (25 September 2026)
- Supports
In December 2018 the Premier League began its own investigation into City.
7The Premier League opens its investigation
- SourceManchester City found guilty of breaking Premier League’s financial fair play rules (25 September 2026)
- Supports
In December 2018 the Premier League began its own investigation into City.
8Feb 2023
- SourceEverything you need to know about Manchester City’s hearing and charges (25 September 2026)
- Supports
In February 2023 the Premier League charged the club with more than 100 rule breaches
9City are charged with more than 100 rule breaches
- SourceEverything you need to know about Manchester City’s hearing and charges (25 September 2026)
- Supports
In February 2023 the Premier League charged the club with more than 100 rule breaches
10Sept 2024
- SourceEverything you need to know about Manchester City’s hearing and charges (25 September 2026)
- Supports
with the process starting in September 2024
11Hearings begin before an independent commission
- SourceEverything you need to know about Manchester City’s hearing and charges (25 September 2026)
- Supports
The counts have been heard by a three-person independent commission, with the process starting in September 2024.
- NoteThis explainer was first published on 15 September 2024 and updated on 25 September 2026.
0:02 · How it got here · narration
12The Premier League’s inquiry is believed to have been inspired by leaked documents.
- SourceManchester City found guilty of breaking Premier League’s financial fair play rules (25 September 2026)
- Supports
In December 2018 the Premier League began its own investigation into City.
- Supports
it is believed to have been inspired by the Football Leaks revelations
0:08 · Friday 25 September
13Fri 25 Sept
- NoteDate: the article was published on Friday 25 September 2026 and says neither party would confirm the outcome “on Friday”.
14News breaks: City are found guilty of the vast majority of more than 100 charges
- SourceManchester City found guilty of breaking Premier League’s financial fair play rules (25 September 2026)
- Supports
Manchester City have been found guilty of the vast majority of more than a hundred charges related to breaches of the Premier League’s financial rules
- Note“More than a hundred” is shown as “more than 100”.
15They face possible relegation, or expulsion from the Premier League
- SourceManchester City found guilty of breaking Premier League’s financial fair play rules (25 September 2026)
- Supports
The serial champions now face the possibility of being relegated from the Premier League, or expelled from the competition altogether
16City deny wrongdoing and are expected to appeal
- SourceTony Pulis says he and Stoke were ‘cheated’ in 2011 FA Cup final after Manchester City verdict (27 September 2026)
- Supports
City are expected to appeal and they deny any wrongdoing.
17More than 100 charges
- SourceEverything you need to know about Manchester City’s hearing and charges (25 September 2026)
- Supports
charged the club with more than 100 rule breaches
- NoteDrawn as a grid of 100 boxes with a plus sign: the articles give different exact totals (see Checks).
0:08 · Friday 25 September · narration
18Now City have been found guilty.
- SourceManchester City found guilty of breaking Premier League’s financial fair play rules (25 September 2026)
- Supports
Manchester City have been found guilty of the vast majority of more than a hundred charges
0:11 · What City won in those seasons
19In the seasons the charges cover, City won
- SourceManchester City found guilty of breaking Premier League’s financial fair play rules (25 September 2026)
- Supports
From season 2009-10 to 2022-23 inclusive City won seven Premier League titles, a Champions League, three FA Cups and six League Cups.
202009-10 to 2022-23
- SourceManchester City found guilty of breaking Premier League’s financial fair play rules (25 September 2026)
- Supports
From season 2009-10 to 2022-23 inclusive
217 Premier League titles
- SourceManchester City found guilty of breaking Premier League’s financial fair play rules (25 September 2026)
- Supports
City won seven Premier League titles
- Note“Seven” written as 7.
226 League Cups
- SourceManchester City found guilty of breaking Premier League’s financial fair play rules (25 September 2026)
- Supports
six League Cups
- Note“Six” written as 6.
233 FA Cups
- SourceManchester City found guilty of breaking Premier League’s financial fair play rules (25 September 2026)
- Supports
three FA Cups
- Note“Three” written as 3.
241 Champions League
- SourceManchester City found guilty of breaking Premier League’s financial fair play rules (25 September 2026)
- Supports
a Champions League
- Note“A Champions League” written as “1”.
0:14 · City’s response
25“The Premier League process remains ongoing”
- SourceManchester City found guilty of breaking Premier League’s financial fair play rules (25 September 2026)
- Supports
A City spokesperson said: “The Premier League process remains ongoing, with significant elements to be completed, and subject to strict confidentiality.
26A Manchester City spokesperson
- SourceManchester City found guilty of breaking Premier League’s financial fair play rules (25 September 2026)
- Supports
A City spokesperson said
27City deny wrongdoing and are expected to appeal
- SourceTony Pulis says he and Stoke were ‘cheated’ in 2011 FA Cup final after Manchester City verdict (27 September 2026)
- Supports
City are expected to appeal and they deny any wrongdoing.
0:14 · City’s response · narration
28City deny wrongdoing.
- SourceTony Pulis says he and Stoke were ‘cheated’ in 2011 FA Cup final after Manchester City verdict (27 September 2026)
- Supports
City are expected to appeal and they deny any wrongdoing.
0:17 · Saturday 26 September
29Sat 26 Sept
- NoteDate: the article says al-Mubarak spoke “on Saturday afternoon”; published Saturday 26 September 2026.
30“Nothing has changed”
- SourceManchester City chair al-Mubarak insists ‘nothing has changed’ after guilty verdict (26 September 2026)
- Supports
“While some people have been quick to reach their own conclusions, and there is so much noise swirling around us, nothing has changed.
- NoteCapital N at the start of a quote used alone.
31Khaldoon al-Mubarak, City chair
- SourceManchester City chair al-Mubarak insists ‘nothing has changed’ after guilty verdict (26 September 2026)
- Supports
Khaldoon al-Mubarak, the Manchester City chair
0:18 · Reported 27 September
32Reported 27 Sept
- NotePublication date of the article. It quotes Pulis’s BBC Sport column without dating it.
33Tony Pulis says his Stoke side were “cheated” in the 2011 FA Cup final
- SourceTony Pulis says he and Stoke were ‘cheated’ in 2011 FA Cup final after Manchester City verdict (27 September 2026)
- Supports
Tony Pulis says he and Stoke were ‘cheated’ in 2011 FA Cup final
From the headline or standfirst, not the body text - Supports
Tony Pulis has said his Stoke City team were “cheated” out of the 2011 FA Cup
34City won that final 1–0
- SourceTony Pulis says he and Stoke were ‘cheated’ in 2011 FA Cup final after Manchester City verdict (27 September 2026)
- Supports
Pulis’s Stoke lost the 2011 Cup final 1-0 after Yaya Touré’s goal.
0:21 · Reported 28 September
35Reported 28 Sept
- NotePublication date of the article. It does not date Mancini’s news conference.
36The charges include alleged failures to give accurate details of player and manager payments
- SourceMancini refers to ‘double’ Manchester City contract and says it ‘isn’t my problem’ (28 September 2026)
- Supports
Among the raft of charges that City faced is an alleged failure to provide accurate details for player and manager payments
37“Manchester City is not guilty and the fact of having a double contract isn’t my problem but theirs, probably”
- SourceMancini refers to ‘double’ Manchester City contract and says it ‘isn’t my problem’ (28 September 2026)
- Supports
Manchester City is not guilty and the fact of having a double contract isn’t my problem but theirs, probably.”
38Roberto Mancini, former City manager
- SourceMancini refers to ‘double’ Manchester City contract and says it ‘isn’t my problem’ (28 September 2026)
- Supports
when he managed Manchester City
0:27 · End card
39Drawn from Guardian journalism
- NoteEnd card heading.
Page header
40Thirty seconds on how a process a decade in the making reached a guilty verdict, and what the club, its former manager and a beaten FA Cup finalist said next.
- NoteSummary of the video. Each element is sourced in the script below.
Checks
- How many charges. The articles differ: 134 (the verdict article), 115 (the chair article), and "more than 100" (the explainer and several others). The video uses "more than 100", which all of them support. The grid of 100 boxes with a plus sign illustrates that figure; it is not a count.
- How the verdict became known. The verdict article says neither party would publicly confirm the outcome on Friday and that City were expected to appeal; the prime minister, Andy Burnham, said "these are reports at this stage". The Guardian nonetheless reports the verdict as fact in its own voice, and the video follows it, alongside City's denial and expected appeal.
- Trophies. The seven titles, six League Cups, three FA Cups and one Champions League are from the verdict article, for seasons 2009-10 to 2022-23 inclusive. The video does not suggest any trophy will be taken away.
- Mancini. The charge context line is from the Mancini article ("an alleged failure to provide accurate details for player and manager payments"). His quote is given in full, including "Manchester City is not guilty".
- Friday 25 September. The verdict article says club executives learned the outcome after a shareholders' meeting on the Thursday; the news broke on the Friday. The screen says "News breaks" under that date. City's denial and expected appeal are shown with the verdict and again in their own beat.
- The explainer's date. "Everything you need to know…" was first published on 15 September 2024 and updated on 25 September 2026, the date the end card gives.
- Dates. "Reported" marks publication dates where the article does not date the remark.
- Left out. Rui Pinto's reaction, the opinion pieces (Barney Ronay, Simon Hattenstone), the Uefa history and Noel Gallagher's and others' reactions. All are credited on the end card.
- Images. None. Type, colour and drawn shapes only. Sound: music and effects synthesised in code; no samples, no licensed music; narration by a synthetic voice (Kokoro, run offline), held to the same sourcing rules.